In 1862, the cornerstone of the new church at the corner of Mentor Avenue and Liberty Street was placed and from that time we have met continuously in this building. A Sunday school building and a Memorial Chapel were added in the 1950’s. In 2001 the foundation under the bell tower was repaired and the steeple was built, painted and shingled by volunteer parishioners. It was raised into position in 2002.
On the front of the Church is a plaque designating it as a member of the Mentor Avenue Historic District which was been entered in the U. S. Department of the Interior’s National Register of Historic Places.